What made this clip a hard test
- Scene selection
- 22 seconds — Walter and Hildy in a dim office two-shot, pendant lamp and night window, B&W grain throughout
- Hardest frame
- Hildy smiling in profile, hat in hand — bright cheek against a dark desk and candlestick telephone; the frame we used for every model comparison
- Source condition
- 640 × 480 MP4 (H.264), ~4.4 MB, ~1.6 Mbps — a typical web rip, with visible grain and soft edges in shadows
- Why not start at 720p?
- We spot-checked a 720p copy of the same scene; it looked cleaner, but 640×480 matches the low-res files many users actually download
- Models compared
- Standard (preview) · Denoise (preview) · Ultra (final export) — Ultra won on faces, suits, and desk detail together
- Success criteria
- Clean shadows, sharp pinstripes and hat edges, readable faces under the lamp — still feels like film, not a filter
- Failure signs
- Waxy skin, halos on edges, flickering detail, or textures that look painted on

